One drawback of studying biology in a model organism is the difficulty of separating essential features from traits that are unique to one species but only of minor significance. We believe that evolutionary comparisons with close relatives provide the best way to address this problem, because each species provides a slightly different viewpoint. Combining these perspectives provides a richer, more complete picture, as in a cubist painting. Genome editing now makes this feasible.For example, our work with
trr-1 (part of the Tip60 HAT complex) led us to focus on how chromatin regulators control the sperm/oocyte decision. We found that mutations in C. briggsae
nurf-1 (part of the Nucleosome Remodeling Factor complex) favored oogenesis. Meanwhile, Li and Kelly showed that mutations in C. elegans
wdr-5 genes (which act in an H3K4 trimethylation complex) favored spermatogenesis. Thus, we compared the functions of each gene in both species. Lowering NURF activity only favored oogenesis in C. briggsae, and had no effect on the sperm/oocyte decision in C. elegans or various male/female species. Hence, we conclude that its role in C. briggsae is a recent adaptation, rather than a general part of the sex-determination pathway. By contrast, we showed that
wdr-5.1(RNAi);
wdr-5.2(null) mutations promote oogenesis in C. briggsae, although they cause the opposite phenotype in C. elegans. Since these mutations affect the same decision, we suspect their biochemical interactions with TRA-1 are conserved; however, the context in which they act must have changed.Sperm activation also plays a critical role in the evolution of hermaphrodites. Five proteins mediate the hermaphrodite activation signal in C. elegans SPE-8, 12, 19, 27 and 29. Mutations in the C. briggsae SPE-8 kinase, the SPE-19 transmembrane protein, and SPE-27 prevent self-fertility, just like in C. elegans. However, null mutants for C. briggsae
spe-29 and
spe-12 appear wild type, which suggests that they do not play a central role in the signal transduction process. The zinc transporter HKE-4.1 also plays a major role in the activation of C. elegans sperm. However, C. elegans sperm can be activated by zinc in vitro, whereas C. briggsae sperm cannot, so we wondered if the role of HKE-4.1 was conserved. Null mutations in C. briggsae
hke-4.1cause cold-sensitive sterility and those in C. tropicalis also cause sterility, so zinc transport plays a conserved role in sperm activation, and is an essential feature of this pathway.