In Caenorhabditis elegans, longevity is increased by a partial loss-of-function mutation in the mitochondrial complex III subunit gene
isp-1. Longevity is also increased by RNAi against the expression of a variety of mitochondrial respiratory chain genes, including
isp-1, but it is unknown whether the
isp-1(
qm150) mutation and the RNAi treatments trigger the same underlying mechanisms of longevity. We have identified
nuo-6(
qm200), a mutation in a conserved subunit of mitochondrial complex I (NUDFB4). The mutation reduces the function of complex I and, like
isp-1(
qm150), results in low oxygen consumption, slow growth, slow behavior, and increased lifespan. We have compared the phenotypes of
nuo-6(
qm200) to those of
nuo-6(RNAi) and found them to be distinct in crucial ways, including patterns of growth and fertility, behavioral rates, oxygen consumption, ATP levels, autophagy, and resistance to paraquat, as well as expression of superoxide dismutases, mitochondrial heat-shock proteins, and other gene expression markers. RNAi treatments appear to generate a stress and autophagy response, while the genomic mutation alters electron transport and reactive oxygen species metabolism. For many phenotypes, we also compared
isp-1(
qm150) to
isp-1(RNAi) and found the same pattern of differences. Most importantly, we found that, while the lifespan of
nuo-6,
isp-1 double mutants is not greater than that of the single mutants, the lifespan increase induced by
nuo-6(RNAi) is fully additive to that induced by
isp-1(
qm150), and the increase induced by
isp-1(RNAi) is fully additive to that induced by
nuo-6(
qm200). Our results demonstrate that distinct and separable aspects of mitochondrial biology affect lifespan independently.