In self-fertile nematodes, XX animals have been modified so that larvae make sperm. Since the XX soma remains female, these changes must be restricted to the germ line. Furthermore, they have to be precisely regulated so the animals can switch to oogenesis as adults. To identify the regulatory changes that underlie this trait, we are comparing the nematodes C. elegans and C. briggsae, and have started work with C. tropicalis. Each species evolved self-fertility independently. These nematodes share a conserved sex-determination pathway that acts through the transcription factor TRA-1, a homolog of the human Gli proteins. Males make HER-1, which binds to and inactivates the TRA- 2 receptor on each cell, allowing the FEM proteins to target TRA-1 for degradation. Females and hermaphrodites lack HER-1, allowing TRA-2 to inhibit the FEM complex. As a result, TRA-1 is cleaved, producing a repressor that turns off male genes. By studying evolutionary change in this pathway we show that: (1) each species has adopted independent and unique solutions for self-fertility, and (2) these regulatory changes can affect almost every step of the pathway upstream of TRA-1. Most of our data come from the direct comparison of similar mutations in different species, made through gene editing. First, the functions of chromatin regulatory complexes have been altered. The Tip60 HAT complex is essential for spermatogenesis in C. briggsae, but plays only a minor role in C. elegans. In addition, the NURF complex is needed for spermatogenesis only in C. briggsae. Finally, mutations that affect the WDR-5 proteins favor oogenesis in C. briggsae, but spermatogenesis in C. elegans. Second, translational regulation has changed dramatically. We analyzed translational control of
fem-3, and found that 3'-UTR mutations that completely block oogenesis in C. elegans result in normal hermaphrodite development in C. briggsae. The Schedl lab showed that in C. elegans, the unique FOG-2 protein works with GLD-1 to block translation of
tra-2 messages, allowing XX spermatogenesis. Finally, the Haag lab has shown that PUF proteins play unique roles in C. briggsae. Third, regulation through protein-protein interactions has been altered. An intracellular fragment of TRA-2 can bind TRA-1 in both C. elegans and C. briggsae. Mutations that prevent this interaction cause oogenesis in C. elegans, but orthologous mutations cause either constitutive spermatogenesis or hermaphrodite development in C. briggsae. Furthermore, C. briggsae relies on the novel SHE-1 protein for self-fertility, and SHE-1 works in part through its binding partner, PQN-94. Thus, selection can alter the sex-determination pathway at almost any point to promote self-fertility. We propose that pathways organized around a binary switch are particularly flexible during evolution, since any change to one of several competing factors should change the final decision.