The accumulation of oxidative damage caused by reactive oxygen species (ROS) has been proposed to be one of the main causes of aging. However, recent work indicates that low levels of ROS can be beneficial and promote longevity. We have shown that while mild elevation of ROS levels causes increased lifespan, high levels of ROS are toxic. To further explore the relationship between ROS and aging, we determined how the subcellular location of ROS impacts the effect of ROS on lifespan. We used a genetic approach to decrease the levels of the antioxidant enzyme superoxide dismutase (SOD) in specific compartments of the cell. Since superoxide is unable to cross membranes, this results in elevated levels of superoxide in the part of the cell in which SOD expression was decreased. To increase our ability to observe an effect of ROS on lifespan, we performed these experiments in
clk-1 mitochondrial mutants, which are sensitized to ROS. We generated
clk-1 double mutants with each of the five C. elegans sod genes and examined the resulting effect on lifespan. We found that increasing superoxide levels in the mitochondria, through the deletion of
sod-2, markedly increased the lifespan of
clk-1 worms. In contrast, increasing the levels of superoxide in the cytoplasm, through deletion of either
sod-1 or
sod-5, resulted in decreased lifespan. This indicates that mitochondrial and cytoplasmic ROS have opposing effects on lifespan. To determine if mitochondrial and cytoplasmic ROS act independently to affect lifespan, we increased mitochondrial ROS in
clk-1;
sod-1 worms through treatment with the superoxide-generator paraquat (PQ). We found that increasing mitochondrial ROS, through treatment with PQ, still increased
clk-1;
sod-1 lifespan. Similarly, we found that increasing cytoplasmic ROS, through deletion of
sod-1, decreased the lifespan of
clk-1;
sod-2 worms, thereby indicating that mitochondrial and cytoplasmic ROS act independently to influence longevity. Finally, we show that the effect of ROS on stress resistance and physiologic rates is also dependent on the location of ROS within the cell, but that both can be experimentally dissociated from lifespan. Overall, this work demonstrates that the relationship between ROS and aging is complex, and that both the levels and location of ROS are crucial in determining the effect of ROS on lifespan.