An important principle of the evolutionary theories of aging is that the force of natural selection diminishes late in life. Based on the principle, two popular theories of aging predict the genes that contribute to aging. The mutation accumulation theory predicts accumulation of the genes (or mutations) with late harmful effects. The antagonistic pleiotropy theory predicts a similar but more focused set of the genes that have early beneficial effects at the cost of late harmful effects (referred to as pleiotropic genes). Although the theories may result in different age-related genetic equilibriums, pleiotropic genes are more or less covered in both of the theories. Pleiotropic genes have been found as a form of mutations or gene inactivation with increased lifespan, which show early deficits in development and reproduction. However, mutations that cause damage early in life are problematic to test, as early damage may affect lifespan. In addition, the genes, which are protective against intrinsic and environmental stress, were not thought to be pleiotropic genes, since they are beneficial throughout lifespan. Here we show that the
sod-4 gene, a gene protective against oxidative stress, is a new type of pleiotropic genes. Using genetic screening combined with in vivo imaging analysis for reactive oxygen species (ROS), we have identified the
sod-4 mutation. The
sod-4 gene is the only C. elegans gene for extracellular superoxide dismutase (EC-SOD), which can scavenge deleterious reactive oxygen species (ROS). Mutations in
sod-4 caused embryonic lethality, delayed development and reduced fertility. Surprisingly, the
sod-4 mutant showed increased fitness during adult phase. The results suggest an unusual example of pleiotropy, which is antagonistic early and late in life. Since recent results questioned the role of age-related oxidative stress in aging, this study offers a first step for more detailed understanding of oxidative stress and aging. Another theory of aging ("midlife crisis" theory) is consistent with the finding, which is being discussed elsewhere.