Hunt PR (2016) J Appl Toxicol "The C. elegans model in toxicity testing."

Hunt PR

[J Appl Toxicol, 2016]

Caenorhabditis elegans is a small nematode that can be maintained at low cost and handled using standard in vitro techniques. Unlike toxicity testing using cell cultures, C. elegans toxicity assays provide data from a whole animal with intact and metabolically active digestive, reproductive, endocrine, sensory and neuromuscular systems. Toxicity ranking screens in C. elegans have repeatedly been shown to be as predictive of rat LD50 ranking as mouse LD50 ranking. Additionally, many instances of conservation of mode of toxic action have been noted between C. elegans and mammals. These consistent correlations make the case for inclusion of C. elegans assays in early safety testing and as one component in tiered or integrated toxicity testing strategies, but do not indicate that nematodes alone can replace data from mammals for hazard evaluation. As with cell cultures, good C. elegans culture practice (GCeCP) is essential for reliable results. This article reviews C. elegans use in various toxicity assays, the C. elegans model's strengths and limitations for use in predictive toxicology, and GCeCP. Published 2016. This article is a U.S. Government work and is in the public domain in the USA. Journal of Applied Toxicology published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd.

Hunt PR et al. (2014) Toxicol Rep "Bioactivity of nanosilver in Caenorhabditis elegans: Effects of size, coat, and shape."

Gao X, Sprando RL, Oldenburg SJ, Bushana P, Hunt PR, Olejnik N, Keltner Z

[Toxicol Rep, 2014]

The in vivo toxicity to eukaryotes of nanosilver (AgNP) spheres and plates in two sizes each was assessed using the simple model organism Caenorhabditis elegans. For each shape, smaller AgNP size correlated with higher toxicity, as indicated by reduced larval growth. Smaller size also correlated with significant increases in silver uptake for silver nanospheres. Citrate coated silver spheres of 20 nm diameter induced an innate immune response that increased or held steady over 24 h, while regulation of genes involved in metal metabolism peaked at 4 h and subsequently decreased. For AgNP spheres, coating altered bioactivity, with a toxicity ranking of polyethylene glycol (PEG) > polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVP) branched polyethyleneimine (BPEI) > citrate, but silver uptake ranking of PEG > PVP > citrate > BPEI. Our findings in C. elegans correlate well with findings in rodents for AgNP size vs. uptake and toxicity, as well as for induction of immune effectors, while using methods that are faster and far less expensive, supporting the use of C. elegans as an alternative model for early toxicity screening.

Hunt PR et al. (2013) J Appl Toxicol "Nanosilver suppresses growth and induces oxidative damage to DNA in Caenorhabditis elegans."

Tyner KM, Conklin S, Nelson BC, Sprando RL, Marquis BJ, Hunt PR, Olejnik N

[J Appl Toxicol, 2013]

Studies on the effects of nanomaterial exposure in mammals are limited, and new methods for rapid risk assessment of nanomaterials are urgently required. The utility of Caenorhabditis elegans cultured in axenic liquid media was evaluated as an alternative in vivo model for the purpose of screening nanomaterials for toxic effects. Spherical silver nanoparticles of 10nm diameter (10nmAg) were used as a test material, and ionic silver from silver acetate as a positive control. Silver uptake and localization, larval growth, morphology and DNA damage were utilized as endpoints for toxicity evaluation. Confocal reflection analysis indicated that 10nmAg localized to the lumen and tissues of the digestive tract of C. elegans. 10nmAg at 10gml(-1) reduced the growth of C. elegans larvae, and induced oxidative damage to DNA as measured by 8-OH guanine levels. Consistent with previously published studies using mammalian models, ionic silver suppressed growth in C. elegans larvae to a greater extent than 10nmAg. Our data suggest that medium-throughput growth screening and DNA damage analysis along with morphology assessments in C. elegans could together provide powerful tools for rapid toxicity screening of nanomaterials.

Hunt PR et al. (2018) Food Chem Toxicol "C. elegans Development and Activity Test detects mammalian developmental neurotoxins."

Olejnik N, Bailey KD, Hunt PR, Sprando RL, Vaught CA

[Food Chem Toxicol, 2018]

Due to the high cost and long duration of traditional testing methods for developmental neurotoxicity (DNT), only a small fraction of chemicals that humans are exposed to have been assessed for DNT activity. In order to ensure public safety, human-predictive methods for DNT detection that are faster and less resource intensive are urgently required. Using Caenorhabditis elegans, a novel worm Development and Activity test (wDAT) has been designed that uses a relatively inexpensive small-animal activity tracker and takes less than 4 days to complete. The wDAT was able to detect both developmental delay and hyperactivity for arsenic, lead, and mercury, heavy metals that are known human developmental neurotoxins and have been associated with hyperactivity in children. Lithium was also tested as a control developmental toxin that is not considered a mammalian neurotoxin. With the wDAT, lithium induced developmental delay but not hyperactivity. This initial assessment of a new assay for DNT detection indicates that the wDAT has potential for detecting at least some types of mammalian developmental neurotoxins. A planned 20-compound validation study will clarify the utility of the wDAT for predicitive toxicology.

Hunt PR et al. (2011) PLoS One "Extension of lifespan in C. elegans by naphthoquinones that act through stress hormesis mechanisms."

Son TG, Camandola S, Greig NH, Wood WH, Zhang Y, Wilson MA, Wolkow CA, Mattson MP, Hunt PR, Yu QS, Becker KG

[PLoS One, 2011]

Hormesis occurs when a low level stress elicits adaptive beneficial responses that protect against subsequent exposure to severe stress. Recent findings suggest that mild oxidative and thermal stress can extend lifespan by hormetic mechanisms. Here we show that the botanical pesticide plumbagin, while toxic to C. elegans nematodes at high doses, extends lifespan at low doses. Because plumbagin is a naphthoquinone that can generate free radicals in vivo, we investigated whether it extends lifespan by activating an adaptive cellular stress response pathway. The C. elegans cap'n'collar (CNC) transcription factor, SKN-1, mediates protective responses to oxidative stress. Genetic analysis showed that skn-1 activity is required for lifespan extension by low-dose plumbagin in C. elegans. Further screening of a series of plumbagin analogs identified three additional naphthoquinones that could induce SKN-1 targets in C. elegans. Naphthazarin showed skn-1dependent lifespan extension, over an extended dose range compared to plumbagin, while the other naphthoquinones, oxoline and menadione, had differing effects on C. elegans survival and failed to activate ARE reporter expression in cultured mammalian cells. Our findings reveal the potential for low doses of naturally occurring naphthoquinones to extend lifespan by engaging a specific adaptive cellular stress response pathway.

Hunt PR et al. (2024) Toxicol Appl Pharmacol "Strengths and limitations of the worm development and activity test (wDAT) as a chemical screening tool for developmental hazards."

Camacho J, Salazar JK, Hamm J, Allen D, Sprando RL, Yourick J, Fay ML, Hunt PR, Fitzpatrick SC, Ceger P, Welch B

[Toxicol Appl Pharmacol, 2024]

The worm Development and Activity Test (wDAT) measures C. elegans developmental milestone acquisition timing and stage-specific spontaneous locomotor activity (SLA). Previously, the wDAT identified developmental delays and SLA level changes in C. elegans with mammalian developmental toxicants arsenic, lead, and mercury. 5-fluorouracil (5FU), cyclophosphamide (CP), hydroxyurea (HU), and ribavirin (RV) are teratogens that also induce growth retardation in developing mammals. In at least some studies on each of these chemicals, fetal weight reductions were seen at mammalian exposures below those that had teratogenic effects, suggesting that screening for developmental delay in a small alternative whole-animal model could act as a general toxicity endpoint to identify chemicals for further testing for more specific adverse developmental outcomes. Consistent with mammalian developmental effects, 5FU, HU, and RV were associated with developmental delays with the wDAT. Exposures associated with developmental delay induced hypoactivity with 5FU and HU, but slight hyperactivity with RV. CP is a prodrug that requires bioactivation by cytochrome P450s for both therapeutic and toxic effects. CP tests as a false negative in several in vitro assays, and it was also a false negative with the wDAT. These results suggest that the wDAT has the potential to identify some developmental toxicants, and that a positive wDAT result with an unknown may warrant further testing in mammals. Further assessment with larger panels of positive and negative controls will help qualify the applicability and utility of this C. elegans wDAT assay within toxicity test batteries or weight of evidence approaches for developmental toxicity assessment.

Hunt PR et al. (2023) J Appl Toxicol "The worm Adult Activity Test (wAAT): A de novo mathematical model for detecting acute chemical effects in Caenorhabditis elegans."

Hunt PR, Sprando RL, Bushana PN, Ferguson M, Welch B, Camacho J, Rand H

[J Appl Toxicol, 2023]

We have adapted a semiautomated method for tracking Caenorhabditis elegans spontaneous locomotor activity into a quantifiable assay by developing a sophisticated method for analyzing the time course of measured activity. The 16-h worm Adult Activity Test (wAAT) can be used to measure C. elegans activity levels for efficient screening for pharmacological and toxicity-induced effects. As with any apical endpoint assay, the wAAT is mode of action agnostic, allowing for detection of effects from a broad spectrum of response pathways. With caffeine as a model mild stimulant, the wAAT showed transient hyperactivity followed by reversion to baseline. Mercury chloride (HgCl₂ ) produced an early dose-response hyperactivity phase followed by pronounced hypoactivity, a behavior pattern we have termed a toxicant "escape response." Methylmercury chloride (meHgCl) produced a similar pattern to HgCl₂ , but at much lower concentrations, a weaker hyperactivity response, and more pronounced hypoactivity. Sodium arsenite (NaAsO₂ ) and dimethylarsinic acid (DMA) induced hypoactivity at high concentrations. Acute toxicity, as measured by hypoactivity in C. elegans adults, was ranked: meHgCl > HgCl₂  > NaAsO₂  = DMA. Caffeine was not toxic with the wAAT at tested concentrations. Methods for conducting the wAAT are described, along with instructions for preparing C. elegans Habitation Medium, a liquid nutrient medium that allows for developmental timing equivalent to that found with C. elegans grown on agar with OP50 Escherichia coli feeder cultures. A de novo mathematical parametric model for adult C. elegans activity and the application of this model in ranking exposure toxicity are presented.

Hunt PR et al. (2012) Food Chem Toxicol "Toxicity ranking of heavy metals with screening method using adult Caenorhabditis elegans and propidium iodide replicates toxicity ranking in rat."

Olejnik N, Robert RS, Hunt PR

[Food Chem Toxicol, 2012]

The utility of any model system for toxicity screening depends on the level of correlation between test responses and toxic reactions in humans. Assays in Caenorhabditis elegans can be fast and inexpensive, however few studies have been done comparing toxic responses in this easily cultured nematode with data on mammalian toxicity. Here we report that a screening assay for acute toxicity, using adult C. elegans grown in axenic liquid culture, replicated LD50 toxicity ranking in rat for five metals. This assay utilized the COPAS Biosort and propidium iodide (PI) as a fluorescent indicator of morbidity and mortality after 30-h exposures. We found that chronic toxicity assays of 2-week treatment duration, followed by analysis of PI induced red fluorescence levels, produced less consistent results than the acute assays. However, other chronic toxicity endpoints were compound and concentration specific, including changes in vulval and gonadal morphology, intestinal thickness and integrity, and the presence of retained internal eggs in post-reproductive animals. Some of these endpoints reflect similar findings in mammals, indicating that measurements of morbidity and mortality in conjunction with morphology analyses in C. elegans may have the potential to predict mammalian toxic responses.

Rudich P et al. (2017) Hum Mol Genet "Nuclear localized C9orf72 associated arginine containing dipeptides exhibit age-dependent toxicity in C. elegans."

Lamitina T, Bhan Pandey U, Watkins SC, Monaghan J, Snoznik C, Rudich P

[Hum Mol Genet, 2017]

A hexanucleotide repeat expansion mutation in the C9orf72 gene represents a prevalent genetic cause of several neurodegenerative diseases, including amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) and frontotemporal dementia (FTD). Non-canonical translation of this repeat gives rise to several distinct dipeptide protein species that could play pathological roles in disease. Here, we show in the model system C. elegans that expression of the arginine-containing dipeptides, but not alanine-containing dipeptides, produces toxic phenotypes in multiple cellular contexts, including motor neurons. Expression of either (PR)50 or (GR)50 during development caused a highly penetrant developmental arrest, while post-developmental expression caused age-onset paralysis. Both (PR)50- and (GR)50-GFP tagged dipeptides were present in the nucleus and nuclear localization was necessary and sufficient for their toxicity. Using an inducible expression system, we discovered that age-onset phenotypes caused by (PR)50 required both continual (PR)50 expression and an aged cellular environment. The toxicity of (PR)50 was modified by genetic mutations that uncouple physiological ageing from chronological ageing. However, these same mutations failed to modify the toxicity of (GR)50, suggesting that (PR)50 and (GR)50 exert their toxicity through partially distinct mechanism(s). Changing the rate of physiological ageing also mitigates toxicity in other C. elegans models of ALS, suggesting that the (PR)50 dipeptide might engage similar toxicity mechanisms as other ALS disease-causing proteins.

Camacho JA et al. (2023) J Dev Biol "Reproductive-Toxicity-Related Endpoints in C. elegans Are Consistent with Reduced Concern for Dimethylarsinic Acid Exposure Relative to Inorganic Arsenic."

Hunt PR, Sprando RL, Welch B, Camacho JA

[J Dev Biol, 2023]

Exposures to arsenic and mercury are known to pose significant threats to human health; however, the effects specific to organic vs. inorganic forms are not fully understood. <i>Caenorhabditis elegans'</i> (<i>C. elegans</i>) transparent cuticle, along with the conservation of key genetic pathways regulating developmental and reproductive toxicology (DART)-related processes such as germ stem cell renewal and differentiation, meiosis, and embryonic tissue differentiation and growth, support this model's potential to address the need for quicker and more dependable testing methods for DART hazard identification. Organic and inorganic forms of mercury and arsenic had different effects on reproductive-related endpoints in <i>C. elegans</i>, with methylmercury (meHgCl) having effects at lower concentrations than mercury chloride (HgCl₂), and sodium arsenite (NaAsO₂) having effects at lower concentrations than dimethylarsinic acid (DMA). Progeny to adult ratio changes and germline apoptosis were seen at concentrations that also affected gravid adult gross morphology. For both forms of arsenic tested, germline histone regulation was altered at concentrations below those that affected progeny/adult ratios, while concentrations for these two endpoints were similar for the mercury compounds. These <i>C. elegans</i> findings are consistent with corresponding mammalian data, where available, suggesting that small animal model test systems may help to fill critical data gaps by contributing to weight of evidence assessments.